Where does Remy rank in the all time discussion?

whether you like his style or not, the guy has beaten a whos who in the sport and is a 3 time gp champ.

1.Semmy
2.Hoost
3.Remy then Aerts or vice versa?

or would you put him behind aerts and hug?

what about Branko?

to me he is top 3 all time. If he came back and won one or two more that would be really impressive, i have read that his eye is still fucked up and thats why he is considering retirement. Shame, he had some wars with badr and other greats, there is probably still a lot of fight left in him.

Below Hari.

Remy wiki page says he pondered .

Sports Channels says he decided .

I hope hes not retire and back 100 percent . Hes top 3 in mine list to.

But number 1 is Cikatic .

2 Shilt & Hoost same to me

And 4th place goes to Aerts.

my top 5 kick boxers of all time

1.Rob Kaman
2.Earnesto Hoost
3.Peter Aerts
4.Branco Cikatic
5.Badr Hari

1.Peter Aerts
2.Ernesto Hoost
3.Semmy Schilt
4.Jerome Le Banner
5.Andy Hug

He's up there but not top 5 and certainly not my favourite.
Badr is my boy but yet he doesnt make it to the top 5

For sure there is a lot of fight left in him. All of him except one eye. He is up there for sure. I cant put a number on him though.

Badr Hari is top 5 even if he never fights again.

If Badr controled his temper he would already have a k-1 title under his belt
along with the others

hope he will be considered one of the best, cause then mcsweeney can say he ahs beat 2 of the best kickboxers in the world

hari is one of the most skilled, but he doesnt have the consistency or the accolades to be ranked top 5.

Hari is the best.

hari is the best, all things considered like "most bad ass, most gangsta ass nigguh, most likely to beat your ass for talking about him on the internet, etc

The top 2 are Hoost and Schilt - undisputed. 4 WGP wins

The 3rd is Aerts - he has the best record in terms of top wins, and has 3 WGP wins

Remy comes right below that - Remy has 3 WGP titles, and a shit load of elite wins too.

He's not above Aerts, and he's damn sure not above Hoost and Schilt, but there are no others you could conceivably rank above Bonjasky, unless you're DAMN biased

The top 4 CAN'T be disputed;

1- Hoost or Schilt
2- Hoost or Schilt
3- Aerts
4- Remy

Jus' sayin'

id like to see Remy come back. One of my all time favs. id def put him in my top 3

1. Hoost
2. Schilt
3. Remy/Aerts (personal preference in this position IMHO)

Can we put Aerts above Schilt? He is 3-2 against him. Even as an old man he still fucked semmy up TWICE. Not really a doubt in my mind who the better kickboxer is.

I have Aerts at #1 too.

Ernesto Hoost #!

santiago, can you post mcsweeney's kickboxing stats i cant find them anywhere online.

goddamnsleepingpill (Wed Dec 15, 2010 3:21 pm) wrote:santiago, can you post mcsweeney's kickboxing stats i cant find them anywhere online.

Lol good luck i cant find it either, besides mcdonald and maybe leko everyone else he beat that was good was in muay thai fights in thailand yrs ago.

I dont know why its impossible to find, ask him maybe he can post it

so who has he beaten and where were the fights? did he really beat REmy and how did he beat him?

leko, mcdonald, Takeru, and remy r the only ones i know of.

I know the remy fight was in thailand, have no idea about the leko fight, and the mcdonald was at cage rage or something,


from wat i heard he stopped him.

but they were also young, so more than likely before remy became as great as he is

REmy is 35, how old is Mcsweeney? it couldnt have been more than 8 or 9 years ago. I dont think mcsweeney is even 28 yet so he was a teenager fighting a man, which actually makes it more impressive if it is true. I wish i could see these fights. War James.

^^ mcsweeney has insane power in his kicks, i was up in the cheap seats at ufc 120 and you could hear the leg kicks he was landing on maldonado up there

^^ though that is the one of two events i have ever been to so i dont have much comparison