Giorgio Petrosyan record - inconsistency with wikipedia
+4
gumby
veprman
DW LiverKick
Fletch
8 posters
Page 1 of 1
Giorgio Petrosyan record - inconsistency with wikipedia
We all know that kickboxing does not have a fightfinder system like boxing and MMA do, on various websites.
Thus, wikipedia is a piece of shit for it and has often terribly incomplete records. Like Melvin, who has 3x more wins than losses, but has more L's showing on his wiki record. POS
Well with Petrosyan, the record is surprisingly well preserved. But while some record listings are incomplete, they still usually have the correct win/loss stats (i.e. Leko is 66-24, which is stated, though only 40 wins or so are shown) but with Petro, it has him 67-1-2, and while it shows just about all of that, he gets announced with more wins at events he fights on.
The shows he fights on have him slightly more advanced i.e. Oktagon 2011 last night announced him 74-1-2, which is obv now 75-1-2 following the win over Cosmo.
So which is right? And what is the best way of finding an accurate kickboxing record these days (wikipedia is a POS)
Thus, wikipedia is a piece of shit for it and has often terribly incomplete records. Like Melvin, who has 3x more wins than losses, but has more L's showing on his wiki record. POS
Well with Petrosyan, the record is surprisingly well preserved. But while some record listings are incomplete, they still usually have the correct win/loss stats (i.e. Leko is 66-24, which is stated, though only 40 wins or so are shown) but with Petro, it has him 67-1-2, and while it shows just about all of that, he gets announced with more wins at events he fights on.
The shows he fights on have him slightly more advanced i.e. Oktagon 2011 last night announced him 74-1-2, which is obv now 75-1-2 following the win over Cosmo.
So which is right? And what is the best way of finding an accurate kickboxing record these days (wikipedia is a POS)
Fletch- Champagne Supernova
- Posts : 13846
Join date : 2010-06-01
Age : 35
Location : Phuket, Thailand
Re: Giorgio Petrosyan record - inconsistency with wikipedia
We're trying to do something about it, but man, it is really, really f'n hard.
http://www.liverkick.com/wikikick/
Yes, we are dead serious about this. So far we have some incomplete records up, mainly because they are a good start for formatting and shit, but we've been contacting gyms trying to fill in the blanks on most records.
If you want to help, you should, as should anyone.
http://www.liverkick.com/wikikick/
Yes, we are dead serious about this. So far we have some incomplete records up, mainly because they are a good start for formatting and shit, but we've been contacting gyms trying to fill in the blanks on most records.
If you want to help, you should, as should anyone.
Re: Giorgio Petrosyan record - inconsistency with wikipedia
I would help. But I have no idea how I could.
veprman- Posts : 2703
Join date : 2010-07-06
Age : 39
Location : Orlando, Fl
Re: Giorgio Petrosyan record - inconsistency with wikipedia
If you learn wiki coding, which isn't too hard, you could put up literally any fighter you can think of that we don't have up there.
The thing we care about most is just the basic facts for now, before we can get more complete records those are kind of an afterthought.
The thing we care about most is just the basic facts for now, before we can get more complete records those are kind of an afterthought.
Re: Giorgio Petrosyan record - inconsistency with wikipedia
did not know this existed............
I think TT could help with this. next week I will start moving some gears, little busy this one.
I think TT could help with this. next week I will start moving some gears, little busy this one.
gumby- The Monk
- Posts : 2615
Join date : 2010-11-03
Re: Giorgio Petrosyan record - inconsistency with wikipedia
Great work Dave, I will edit in Masatos 55-0 record when I have the chance. The 5 losses dont count for various obvious reasons, think we can all agree on that .
On a more serious note that is a great idea, I will look through my fight library and see if there is anything I can add.
On a more serious note that is a great idea, I will look through my fight library and see if there is anything I can add.
Re: Giorgio Petrosyan record - inconsistency with wikipedia
Building a database of kickboxing records is way harder
than MMA since Kickboxers are more active and theres no
such thing as exclusivity.I hope u manage to create your
database although its very hard
than MMA since Kickboxers are more active and theres no
such thing as exclusivity.I hope u manage to create your
database although its very hard
bfnick- Posts : 1836
Join date : 2010-08-20
Location : Greece
Re: Giorgio Petrosyan record - inconsistency with wikipedia
Yeah, it is hard, but I figure if enough people help out on it, there is a good chance to at least make it better than wikipedia.
Re: Giorgio Petrosyan record - inconsistency with wikipedia
great work
You're fucked with people like Dekkers and Kaman though.... Dekkers has 200+ fights, many of which are unlisted and were on smaller shows, and Kaman doesnt even have his proper record listed in many places.
But you're doing great work Dave!
You're fucked with people like Dekkers and Kaman though.... Dekkers has 200+ fights, many of which are unlisted and were on smaller shows, and Kaman doesnt even have his proper record listed in many places.
But you're doing great work Dave!
Fletch- Champagne Supernova
- Posts : 13846
Join date : 2010-06-01
Age : 35
Location : Phuket, Thailand
Re: Giorgio Petrosyan record - inconsistency with wikipedia
mad props for even attempting this kickboxing database
im gonna try to help by adding fighters, dunno about records
its really easy to add just the basic information of the fighter, I've put in like 4 or 5 pages so far to get started. can't figure out the record part yet
im gonna try to help by adding fighters, dunno about records
its really easy to add just the basic information of the fighter, I've put in like 4 or 5 pages so far to get started. can't figure out the record part yet
Soy Chingon- Posts : 1958
Join date : 2010-12-06
Age : 33
Location : Calgary, Canada
Re: Giorgio Petrosyan record - inconsistency with wikipedia
Even if fighters from the past cant be completed, at least the fighters of today are being recorded!!!!
This will only get better
This will only get better
Fletch- Champagne Supernova
- Posts : 13846
Join date : 2010-06-01
Age : 35
Location : Phuket, Thailand
Re: Giorgio Petrosyan record - inconsistency with wikipedia
cmon guys help out with this. it's pretty easy, even if you just wanna add the basic info. maybe i just have too much time on my hands
Soy Chingon- Posts : 1958
Join date : 2010-12-06
Age : 33
Location : Calgary, Canada
Re: Giorgio Petrosyan record - inconsistency with wikipedia
I want to as well but I would rather email some gyms before I go through my old HDD disks of k-1 fights.
even beyond the records I think we should have tourney results from K-1 and such, gym pages, etc.,
even beyond the records I think we should have tourney results from K-1 and such, gym pages, etc.,
gumby- The Monk
- Posts : 2615
Join date : 2010-11-03
Re: Giorgio Petrosyan record - inconsistency with wikipedia
Oh yeah, those will absolutely be on there.
The idea for right now was we tried to get everyone for the last It's Showtime fight up. When we couldn't make that (I went on vacation, Fraser's kid got sick) we made sure the top 30 or so in HW and MW were completed at least.
From there we want to do, obviously, shows, gyms, promotions and title records.
We are mostly focused, for the time being, on going forward. So it is most important to make sure upcoming guys are in there.
The idea for right now was we tried to get everyone for the last It's Showtime fight up. When we couldn't make that (I went on vacation, Fraser's kid got sick) we made sure the top 30 or so in HW and MW were completed at least.
From there we want to do, obviously, shows, gyms, promotions and title records.
We are mostly focused, for the time being, on going forward. So it is most important to make sure upcoming guys are in there.
Re: Giorgio Petrosyan record - inconsistency with wikipedia
Oh, and really, any help you guys provide is really incredible and I appreciate it.
Re: Giorgio Petrosyan record - inconsistency with wikipedia
Dave would you be alright with guys like me and soy saying that this is on behalf of LiverKick.com?
when we email gyms/managers I mean
when we email gyms/managers I mean
gumby- The Monk
- Posts : 2615
Join date : 2010-11-03
Re: Giorgio Petrosyan record - inconsistency with wikipedia
Yeah of course, just say you are working on a project for LiverKick, if you need a ref or anything if they give you a hard time (they won't) just ask and I'll bug them.
Re: Giorgio Petrosyan record - inconsistency with wikipedia
I'm already happy that so much information is available by Wikipedia.
Re: Giorgio Petrosyan record - inconsistency with wikipedia
On the WikiKick front --
Got a logo up and got image uploads fixed.
Got a logo up and got image uploads fixed.
Similar topics
» Giorgio Petrosyan vs Cosmo Alexandre, Armen Petrosyan vs Yoshihiro Sato fight card in an hour
» Tell me about Giorgio Petrosyan and why he's so good
» Will Giorgio Petrosyan fight again in November on It Showtime event in Tenerife?
» Giorgio Petrosyan is the fedor of kickboxing right now
» Giorgio Petrosyan Decisions Sudsakorn Sor Klinmee
» Tell me about Giorgio Petrosyan and why he's so good
» Will Giorgio Petrosyan fight again in November on It Showtime event in Tenerife?
» Giorgio Petrosyan is the fedor of kickboxing right now
» Giorgio Petrosyan Decisions Sudsakorn Sor Klinmee
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
|
|